If you’ve seen the Maysles brothers’ concert documentary Gimme Shelter, you know the story of what happens in the clip below: Jefferson Airplane begins performing “The Other Side of This Life” during their set at the infamous 1969 Altamont Speedway Free Music Festival, held just east of San Francisco two years after the Summer of Love and less than four months after the comparatively peaceful Woodstock.

Jefferson Airplane’s performance marks the moment on that dark day in rock history when the atmosphere of violence that had been brewing — created by the Hells Angels — ratchets up several notches. The Angels had been brought in by the Rolling Stones, on recommendation from the Grateful Dead (and, some say, from the Airplane, too), to work “security” at the event.

[Minute 4:51] Kantner to the crowd: “Hey man, I’d like to mention that the Hells Angels just smashed [Airplane singer] Marty Balin in the face and knocked him out for a bit. [In a dry, sarcastic tone] I’d like to thank you for that.”

A Hells Angel grabs a microphone: “Is this on? If you’re talking to me, I’m gonna talk to you.”

Kantner: “I’m not talking to you, I’m talking to the people who hit my lead singer in the head.”

Hells Angel: “You’re talking to my people.”

Kantner: “Right.”

Hells Angel: “Let me tell you what’s happening: You are what’s happening.”

[Minute 5:19] A few Angels, wielding weapons, begin beating the shit out of hippies in a pit in front of the stage.

Within a few hours, one of the Angels, Alan Passaro, will fatally stab an 18-year-old Black kid — Berkeley art student Meredith Hunter, who’d left the stage area earlier to get his handgun after becoming freaked out by the violence. The Stones are unaware of the gun or the killing as they segue from “Sympathy for the Devil” to “Under My Thumb” amid total chaos on and off the stage. (The Angels would later attempt an assassination of Mick Jagger at his holiday home in New York’s Hamptons, as revenge, but the plan failed when the boat they were using overturned in stormy waters, according to the FBI.)

Meanwhile, the ’60s peace-and-love vibe suffers irreparable damage.

Paul Kantner, Marty Balin, and, later, Keith Richards were the only three rockers who were documented at Altamont pointedly standing up to the Angels. Years later, Kantner would go into more detail about that day with Bay Area music writer David Gans, explaining that rock festivals shouldn’t be exercises in control — particularly by a motorcycle gang whose members were paid in beer.

“There is no control — that’s the glory of a rock concert,” Kantner said. “The glory of the outdoor rock concert a la what the Stones tried to do [at Altamont] — and what we had been doing for years here, and probably what John Philip Sousa did in open-air sheds in the eighteen-whatevers — is the lack of control, and [the] enjoyment. There is no need for control. That’ s why Altamont was such a shock.”

Ironically, the only problem at Altamont, according to Kantner, were the gang members who were hired to work the “security” detail. “Nobody was out of control except the Hells Angels — put it that way,” Kantner said.

Kantner stopped short of blaming the Angels as an organization, though, pointing out that at many events in San Francisco, the motorcycle gang had been helpful. “The bikers were the babysitters at the Human Be-In, [taking care of] lost children,” he said. “They didn’t have an altogether bad reputation.”

He blamed specific Angels — younger ones who didn’t understand biker protocol. “It turned out that most of [the veteran Angels] were having a big meeting in Oakland [on the day of the Altamont festival, and] a lot of the guys who were there [at the concert] and causing a lot of the hassle were neophytes, young would-be’s — early trainees, as it were. The older guys, who usually keep them in line … weren’t present that day … I don’t blame it on the Hells Angels. I blame it on the [Angels] who were there, but I don’t characterize that as ‘the Hells Angels.'”

Well, it’s not exactly true that only neophytes were there: Sonny Barger, founder of the Oakland chapter of the motorcycle gang, was present, standing next to the stage, drinking beer, doing absolutely nothing while his goons were beating up hippies. But I’ll give Kantner a break for his faulty memory.

There’s so much I could write about Paul Kantner, who died last week at 74. But I chose this story because I’d always admired his behavior at Altamont and wanted to learn more about his experience that day. I remember walking away from Gimme Shelter as a kid, bummed out, my illusions of the ’60s shattered — but with even more respect for Kantner than I’d had before. (And I already had a lot of respect for him.) Now, I saw Kantner not only as an idealist who sang psychedelicized folk songs that resonated with me, and wrote concept albums about exploring other worlds, but also as a ballsy dude willing to stand up to a Hells Angel.

Kantner’s music and worldview had helped me get through high school during a time in North Carolina when bikers and rednecks also terrorized Southern kids who just wanted to have fun, listen to music, and be free of the burdens of the world for a little while. On a smaller scale than Altamont, these local bikers would stop outdoor concerts, get in fights, threaten newspaper reporters, and generally wreak havoc over silly spats nobody else cared about. Some of their defenders and sympathizers are the very same people who criticize (at best) Black gang members today.

What’s more, my time in high school happened to coincide with some of the most musically vacuous years in rock history: 1975 to 1977 — the era when rock went so corporate that any element of experimentation had been squelched. It was just after glam rock’s heyday, after Southern rock had begun to lose its drawl, but before punk rock took root (at least in my neck of the woods). While most of the white rock heads at my school were listening to Boston, Kiss, and Ted Nugent, I would steal away to my car at lunch and bliss out to the Jefferson Airplane, Quicksilver Messenger Service, Country Joe & the Fish, the Grateful Dead’s Anthem of the Sun, or the Allman Brothers’ “Dreams.”

I wanted 1976 to be 1967. I felt that I’d missed out. I wasn’t fully cognizant of punk yet, and I wasn’t appreciative of R&B unless it was earlier soul, Sly & the Family Stone, or Funkadelic.

Jefferson Airplane took me far away from the bullshit of high school. I couldn’t get enough of Surrealistic Pillow, Crown of Creation, After Bathing at Baxter’s, and Volunteers, and I was at just the right age to be seduced by the sci-fi storyline of Blows Against the Empire, Kantner’s first album as Jefferson Starship. I wanted to blast off into space, and his songs told me that this was a distinct possibility.

In “Hijack,” from Empire, Kantner sang:

You know, a starship circling in the sky — it ought to be ready by 1990.
They’ll be building it up in the air, even since 1980.
People with a clever plan can assume the role of the mighty,
and hijack the starship, carry 7,000 people past the sun.
And our babes’ll wander naked through the cities of the universe.

I believed it. I was ready to sign up. I also believed Kantner’s lyrics about peace and love and freedom in songs spanning from the psychedelic-folk of “Martha” to the anti-establishment pronouncements of “Crown of Creation” to the youthful, celebratory “We Can Be Together,” among many others. The Airplane would be part of my roadmap out of the world that I came from — the small-town Southern world that, if I stuck around, would have me working in a factory. I was so intent on leaving my hometown behind that I planned a pilgrimage to San Francisco at 18 — exactly one decade too late.

The summer after graduation, in 1978, my friend Jeff and I hit the road — long hair, short cut-off jeans, a half-pound of pot, and 100-percent naivety. A few weeks later, we arrived in the Haight-Ashbury with a map that I’d cut out of Rolling Stone.  We immediately dropped by the Airplane house (Kantner and company were long gone, of course), copped some acid, went to a Country Joe & the Fish reunion show, saw Grateful Dead lyricist Robert Hunter perform in a bar, and generally pretended to be hippies for the rest of the summer.

Jeff and me on the road to San Francisco in 1978

Then we returned home to attend college; I discovered punk rock and moved on. But I never stopped liking the Airplane, even after Kantner himself sold out to the corporate-rock ogre (though I could never listen to later Starship records).

Fast-forward to today, more than 30 years later, after decades of crisscrossing the country, living in New York, Los Angeles, and back home in North Carolina: I’ve made my home in the Bay Area. I like it here, even though it has changed dramatically. There’s still something magical in the air. I like seeing the Golden Gate Bridge when I look out over the bay, and driving by People’s Park in Berkeley, and running into Country Joe now and then.

In the past few days, I’ve read a lot of Kantner obits from people who knew him, people who didn’t, and people who have no clue of anything his bands have done aside from “Somebody To Love,” “Miracles,” the tepid “Jane,” and the god-awful “We Built This City on Rock & Roll.” I’ve heard people say Kantner was a jerk, he was a grump, he was this and that. When I heard of his death on Thursday, I was disappointed that I never got the chance to run into him. But now I’m OK with it. Nothing will spoil my memories of his music helping me get through high school and out of Dodge. Or that indelible image of him talking back to a Hells Angel.

Godspeed, Paul. You were the ultimate dreamer. You fought the good fight. You stood up to the Angels. And now, you’ve finally hijacked that starship. You’ve reached the second door. You’re swirling together with 7,000 gypsies.


Enjoy this rich sampling of Kantner’s music from the earliest days of the Airplane to his blast-off with the Starship. His recorded output began to suffer in the late ’70s when the Starship evolved into a pedestrian hard rock band, but there have been bright spots — most notably Jefferson’s Tree of Liberty, a set of cover versions of protest songs by the likes of Bob Dylan, Phil Ochs, and Woody Guthrie that Kantner recorded as Jefferson Starship in 2008. However, I’ve focused here on his strongest years as a psychedelic folk-rock pioneer: 1966 to 1973.


  1. I just stumbled on this article and I feel the need to protest the premise. The late Paul Kantner did call out the Angles on the mic but the only musician to truly stand up against them was Marty Balin. Keith Richards and Kantner did take a risk with their lip service but only one guy actually went into the audience to help. And he paid for it dearly.

  2. I wanted to add more to my other comment but this blogspace won’t allow edits, so please pardon this second comment.
    Since this is a posting memorializing Paul Kantner I would like to share a PK story. I have lived in San Francisco for 20 years, and in that time I have had three odd interactions with or around members of Jefferson Airplane. Which makes sense, as they are known to be odd people. For Paul Kantner I offer this. When I was still in my early 20s (late 90s_ I was riding on a San Francisco bus which suddenly slammed on the brakes. A screeching halt, in fact, due to someone in front of the bus making a sudden and unexpected stop. The bus driver cursed as we pulled around the offending car. I looked out the window to see a black Mercedes Benz that was apparently piloted by a shaggy haired guy in glasses who was now spray painting over a “No Parking” sign with black paint. Yes, it was Paul Kantner. I had never seen a rock star in the wild before, and certainly would not expect to see on involved in such randomness. Of course, I got off at the next stop and hurried back to the spot but he was gone, leaving only a freshly obscured parking sign in his wake. I can only assume that he had received a ticket and was going to fight it in court.
    Old timers here in SF are never surprised by this story about PK, btw.

  3. Thanks for your comments, Mike. You’re right — Marty’s the one who got roughed up and he should be commended for that. When he dies, perhaps I’ll tell that story.

  4. BS. The only Angels there were the newbies and the heirarchy were holding a meeting elsewhere? Sonny Barger was there, and he was the head of the Oakland chapter for years. Kantner was just lucky he didnt get his head knocked off.

  5. Meredith Hunter was responsible for Meredith Hunte’s death. He pointed a handgun at point blank range at the stage. If he had been white, it would’ve been forgotten about soon enough.
    And the helicopter pilot telling the people who brought Meredith’s corpse to the helicoopter, “This helicopter is reserved for The Rolling Stones,” is complete bullshit. If that had been true, the helicopter pilot would’ve been charged as an accesory to murder.
    Where were you all when I was gay bashed, walking through Volnteer Park in Seattle n 1988? Your concern rings false and alien to me.

  6. You lost me at “if he had been white.” Any seriousness I may have taken your comment evaporated at that point.

  7. If it’s true the crowd were pushing the Angel’s bikes (which is what George Christie said in the History Channel’s Outlaw Chronicles) and that Marty said “Eff you x 3” to the Angel who was trying to hold it all together, then it’s no surprise he got lumped up for being mouthy.

    Hippies or not, Flower children or not, you touch a man’s bike and you reap what you sow. It’d probably be better for you to be touching his children. Superstar artist, rock star or not, mouth off to the Hells Angels, and they will show you very quickly that you ain’t crap. I’ve seen the videos, how come nobody ever mentions the head case who was killed pulled out a gun? And that the Angel who killed him was found to have committed lawful self defense? As I said, I’ve seen the videos and if the Angels weren’t there, that crowd would have been gangbanging Grace Slick right on the stage.

    Finally, ask yourselves why the Angels never had any problems at Dead shows? Because the crowd and the band knew how to behave with the HA. Don’t touch the bikes, don’t give the HA any crap. What’s so hard about that?

  8. The Oakland chapter with Barger wasn’t there when Paul Kantner stood up to the Angels (see Barger book “Hells Angel” page 162). They arrived later, when Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young played. But the Frisco chapter were all there, Pete Knell, William Fritsch and other veterans. It was Fritsch who came up to the microphone to answer Kantner. The Angel who knocked out Marty Balin was called Animal, and he was a veteran in the club. Real name Paul Hibbits. He’s the one in the movie with an animal fur hat.

  9. Thanks for clarifying, Arnt! From my understanding (and I very well may be misinformed), Barger had been present during that dust-up, but most of the members of the Oakland chapter were not. And this guy in the purple shirt looks to me like Barger. Is it not him?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.